I hate giving skin care advice. Everyone’s skin is different and it can change on a dime depending on the weather, hormones, stress levels, and the effects of medications and illnesses. What works for one person may not work for another. Or worse.
My skin is extremely oily. Extremely oily. Actually even that’s an understatement and it only got worse after I stopped smoking (I didn’t believe that cigarettes were “drying out” my skin until I quit and saw the post-smoking levels of oil my skin produced!). I’ve struggled most of my life with products and regimines that were “good enough” or “the best I could hope for” in managing it. I’ve been lucky the last few years that I’ve found a couple of products that work well for me toward that end – I do so enjoy not looking like an oil slick before I even manage to get to work – and some old favorites that continue to work well. So rather than give anyone advice, I’d like to simply share with you some basic skin care products that I love and that work well for me and my super oily skin. I will talk about body care and skin treatments in their own seperate posts. Please feel free to chime in via the comments and let us know what’s working for you!
Mattifiers/Oil control Moisturizers
The first mattifier I ever tried was in college. It was by Clean & Clear, and it did nothing except dry my face out horribly. I actually wound up with a really bad case of windburn because of it.
Fortunately, I found MAC Oil Control Lotion a few years ago, and it changed the way I think about mattifiers. It’s kind of pricey at $33 for 1.7 oz, but at the time, I thought it was well worth it. It moisturizes and primes skin for makeup without being too heavy, and it does do a great job of controlling oil throughout the day. I found that when I used it I didn’t have to blot or touch up my powder near as much. But it didn’t leave my skin dry, tight, or feeling chapped, even if I wore it alone.
Not long ago, Olay debuted their Fresh Effects line, geared toward younger women. Then they immediately retooled it, getting rid of some products and adding others with more of an acne-control slant. This has been good and bad – the good part being that they added their Swirled Mattifier, a moisturizer that not only controls oil very well, but reduces redness in the skin and even helps with the appearance of large pores! It costs anywhere between $6.99 and $9.99 for 40ml (about an ounce?) so it’s much cheaper than the MAC product. I love the slight green tint, which helps if you sometimes have redness in your skin. I’ve been using the product since it debuted and I simply adore it. It moisturizes just enough that my skin feels soft and supple, but not enough that it feels heavy or overdone. It controls oil pretty well, too – I can tell the difference in how my makeup lasts over the course of the day and I have noticed that when I wear this alone I don’t have a slick, shiny appearance after a couple of hours.
Neither of these products completely eliminates any shine nor the need for touch ups. My skin is just too severely oily and it will find a way! But I’ve had great success with both of these products and will continue to use them.
Gel Cream Moisturizers
Most of the moisturizers I’ve tried have been less than ideal for my skin. Even my once-beloved Olay Total Effects usually felt like a heavy layer sitting on my skin. With as much oil as my skin produced that was not a good thing – within minutes of applying a moisturizer, even a light “oil free” one, my skin would look (and yes, sometimes feel) greasy. For the longest time, I just accepted it. That was the way it was going to be, and there was little I could do about it. Until I rediscovered gel cream moisturizers.
My first experience with this miracle came when I was nineteen or twenty years old and bought my first Victoria Jackson cosmetics kit. If you’re my age or older, you remember the infomercials for her foundation (“the no makeup makeup”) and color kits. My original color kit came with a sample sized jar of her gel cream moisturizer, and I was hooked. It was probably the first product that made my skin feel great. Too bad it was pricey and hard to get (their customer service was really horrible back in the day) especially for a young lady about to start college and who didn’t have a regular job! As much as I loved it, I did without for years. I honestly can’t recall ever seeing another product like it until a few years ago – it’s very possible the high-end brands were doing it, and I just didn’t have exposure/access.
And then Olay debuted Fresh Effects. The first product I tried when the line first came out was their Dew Over moisturizer. It was a light gel cream that went on smooth as silk and absorbed quickly into my skin. It didn’t ever feel heavy or greasy. It didn’t control the oil my skin produced, but it didn’t add to it much either. I loved this product so much! Unfortunately, as I’ve already mentioned, Olay retooled this brand and Dew Over was one of the casualties. You can still find the product on Amazon for now, but it’s much more expensive now that it’s basically been discontinued (sometimes it’s as much as $19.00 for a 1.7 oz jar!).
I’ve already went looking for a suitable replacement. At the moment, I’m using Garnier’s Moisture Rescue and I like it so far. It was around $6.99 on Amazon. Neutrogena makes a version of the gel cream moisturizer, as well, but I haven’t tried it yet. It’s a little more expensive (I believe I saw it at Target for $19.99) and I have had bad experiences with their products before. The plus is that they do have a complete line including one for around the eyes, which is tempting. As long as none of them contain aloe, I might try them in the future.
Night Cream
I’ve used several night creams over the years with mixed results. Most people will tell you that they are a good idea since they are supposed to be formulated to work while the skin is at rest, but they do tend to be heavier than day time formulas and thus, those of us with oily skin tend to shy away. Up until last week I had been alternating between using a nighttime treatment and one of my gel creams. Then I decided to try Olay Active Botanicals Intensive Night Cream. It’s been less than a week, so I’m not really sure what I think yet. So far it doesn’t feel horribly heavy and I don’t seem to wake up with a greasy face.
Sunscreen
If you have severely oily skin like I do, you hate the mere mention of sunscreen. Even if you don’t have oily skin, if you’ve used a moisturizer without sunscreen and then the same product with added SPF, you know there’s a huge difference in how it feels and performs. I try to steer clear of moisturizers containing it completely, instead opting for SPF in my makeup for every day (Lasting by Merle Norman is SPF 12) and I always have a parasol or other appliance when I have to be in the sun.
For those times when I’m not wearing makeup (like when I’m lounging by the pool or on a beach vacation) I keep Cotz Face on hand. This is another product my husband found that I now cannot live without. It’s a mineral sunscreen specifically for the face (and it comes in pale skin tones!). It’s never heavy, doesn’t have a horrid smell, and it keeps it’s matte look for hours. I’ve been using it since 2011 and I couldn’t be more pleased. The price varies at Amazon – at the time of writing, it was $15.99 for a 1.5 oz tube, but the first time my husband got it for me it was retailing for almost $40.00!
Cleansers and Acne Control
When I first stopped smoking, my dermatologist put me on an Rx acne face wash that was 2% benzoyl peroxide. It helped, but it was expensive and it didn’t foam. Lather doesn’t necessarily equal clean, but it is what most of us are used to and find easiest to work with. I knew already from years of experience that salicylic acid didn’t do anything for me except dry my skin out and make it peel, so I went with it and it did help.
Then by sheer accident I discovered PanOxyl. I first saw it at Wal-Mart, but it’s also available at many Target and grocery stores, and is also available on Amazon. For between $9.99 and $13.00 (depending on where you buy) you get 5.5 oz of foaming face wash that packs a powerful 10% benzoyl peroxide solution without a prescription. It works so well for me that I hate being without it. I use it every morning in the shower and I rarely (if ever) have to use any kind of spot treatment.
To remove makeup, I like cold cream. I’ve tried many over the years, but my favorite was always the C&O Bigelow Rose Cold Cream, once sold by Bath & Bodyworks. Of course, it was discontinued! Fortunately, Merle Norman makes a very similar product (much cheaper and in bigger jars!) that I was very happy to find.
I jumped on the micellular water bandwagon, mostly because I hoped it would remove my eye makeup. It didnt. But I was really surprised at how much makeup my cold cream missed. I’m undecided on whether I will give Simple another go or try something else.
After the gym, I use another Olay Fresh Effect product that’s about to disappear – Shine Shine Go Away. A couple of times a week, I use it on concert with a battery operated face brush (mine is a Conair, and it came with a facial sauna). I stocked up on this cleanser after it first came out (I found it for $3.00 a bottle at a Big Lots store). I’m not sure what I’ll do when I finally run out!
And finally, for gentle exfoliating, I stick with the classic St. Ives Apricot Scrub. I have yet to find anything affordable and accessible that works better. The exfoliators in the formula are all natural – ground walnut shell and apricot seed – which is a huge plus. You can get it in just about any major drug or grocery store and it leaves my skin feeling soft and wonderful.
I am still looking for a good eye makeup remover and a good daytime, non-retinol eye cream. In both cases the most highly recomended products contain aloe, which I am allergic to.